THIS TOWN AIN'T BIG ENOUGH FOR THE BOTH OF US (2026): Cast, Story

Prepared by Movies Dock Editorial

This Town Ain't Big Enough for the Both of Us is a six-minute western comedy romance about Aubrey and Indiana, two women who connect over unhappy marriages and find themselves drawn into a secret romance. Written and directed by Ben Stitch, the short film was shot on Super8.

This Town Ain't Big Enough for the Both of Us is a short western comedy romance written and directed by Ben Stitch. With a six-minute runtime and a Super8 presentation, the film centers on an unexpected connection between two women living within unhappy marriages.

Emilia Perrone plays Aubrey, while Michelle San Reis plays Indiana, described as a wannabe cowboy. The story’s romantic premise is complicated by the discovery of their relationship, bringing their husbands, Silas and Milo, into the conflict.

THIS TOWN AIN'T BIG ENOUGH FOR THE BOTH OF US movie details

Story without spoilers

Aubrey meets Indiana, a woman with cowboy ambitions, and the two discover common ground in their unhappy marriages. Their bond develops into a romance, but the relationship is not kept private for long. Once their husbands learn what has happened, the film raises the question of what consequences may follow for both women.

The premise combines the recognizable tensions of a secret romance with the language and setting associated with a western. Its very short runtime suggests a compact, focused story rather than an expansive character drama, while the comedy and romance elements provide a lighter frame for the central conflict.

What to expect

The film is identified as a Western, Comedy and Romance, so viewers can expect those three modes to shape its premise. The western element is reinforced by Indiana’s wannabe-cowboy identity and the film’s tagline, “A Lesbian Cowboy Film Shot on Super8.”

At six minutes, the story has limited space for development and is likely to work as a concise short-form narrative. The Super8 format is also a defining part of its stated identity, alongside the relationship between Aubrey and Indiana and the complication created by their husbands’ discovery.

Cast and creative team

Emilia Perrone plays Aubrey, and Michelle San Reis plays Indiana. Sid Plimmer appears as Silas, while Michal Widecki plays Milo. Ben Stitch wrote and directed the film.

• Emilia Perrone as Aubrey
• Michelle San Reis as Indiana
• Sid Plimmer as Silas
• Michal Widecki as Milo

Release and production context

This Town Ain't Big Enough for the Both of Us is a 2026 film with a listed release date of October 23, 2026. It has a runtime of six minutes and is produced by Beautiful Pictures. The supplied information identifies it as a short film shot on Super8, but does not specify a country or spoken language.

Production companies: Beautiful Pictures

Reported production figures:
Budget $2,000

Movies Dock view

With its brief runtime, western framing and Super8 presentation, This Town Ain't Big Enough for the Both of Us sets up a sharply defined romantic conflict. The film’s central focus is Aubrey and Indiana’s connection, and the pressure placed on it when their husbands become aware of the relationship.

Film data:
TMDB · IMDb