The Pastor Who Preys (2026): Cast, Story and Release Details

Prepared by Movies Dock Editorial

The Pastor Who Preys follows Nicole, an aspiring fashion designer who heads to a small lakeside town for the summer. After her cousin Amanda dies in what appears to be a mysterious accident, Nicole begins questioning the circumstances and looking for answers.

The Pastor Who Preys is a mystery thriller centered on Nicole, a budding fashion designer whose summer plans change after a family tragedy. What begins as a seasonal move to a small lakeside town soon becomes an investigation into a death that does not seem straightforward.

Directed by Linden Ashby and written by Michael Perronne, the film is presented as a TV Movie with an English-language cast and an 86-minute runtime. Its story combines a personal search for the truth with the tension of a suspicious death in a close-knit setting.

The Pastor Who Preys movie details

Story without spoilers

Nicole Alday relocates to a small lakeside town for the summer, where she intends to work on her first fashion collection and spend time with her cousin, Amanda Barrington. Those plans are disrupted when Amanda dies in a mysterious accident.

As Nicole considers what happened, she starts to suspect that the circumstances surrounding Amanda’s death may not be what they appear to be. The film’s central mystery follows Nicole’s effort to understand the event while navigating the people connected to the town and the Barrington family.

What to expect

The film is categorized as a mystery, thriller and TV Movie, so viewers can expect a story built around suspicion, unanswered questions and an investigation driven by a personal connection. The lakeside-town setting provides the backdrop for Nicole’s search for clarity, while the premise keeps the focus on whether Amanda’s death was truly accidental.

The supplied details establish a suspense-oriented narrative without revealing its resolution. The emphasis is on Nicole’s growing doubts and the information she uncovers as she attempts to make sense of the tragedy.

Cast and creative team

Amanda Nicholas leads the cast as Nicole Alday. Daniel Stine plays Caleb Whitley, with Clark Sarullo as Jenn Whitley and Annette Saunders as Hattie Whitley. Analisa Wall portrays Amanda Barrington, while Erika Monet Butters plays Lacey and Maxie McClintock appears as Taylor Caldwell.

Trevor Lyons plays Tom Barrington, Wade Hunt Williams portrays Detective Chandler, and Allen C. Shepherd Sr. plays Alex. Linden Ashby directs from a screenplay by Michael Perronne.

• Amanda Nicholas as Nicole Alday
• Daniel Stine as Caleb Whitley
• Clark Sarullo as Jenn Whitley
• Annette Saunders as Hattie Whitley
• Analisa Wall as Amanda Barrington
• Erika Monet Butters as Lacey
• Maxie McClintock as Taylor Caldwell
• Trevor Lyons as Tom Barrington
• Wade Hunt Williams as Detective Chandler
• Allen C. Shepherd Sr. as Alex

Release and production context

The Pastor Who Preys is a United States production from Lifetime and Studio TF1 America. It is listed as released on October 8, 2026, and has a runtime of 1 hour and 26 minutes. The film’s spoken language is English, and its genres are Mystery, Thriller and TV Movie.

Production companies: Lifetime, Studio TF1 America

Movies Dock view

With its fashion-designer protagonist, lakeside setting and suspicious family death, The Pastor Who Preys frames its mystery through Nicole’s personal search for answers. The concise runtime and TV Movie format keep the premise focused on the circumstances surrounding Amanda’s death and the questions that follow.

Film data:
TMDB · IMDb